Those Is What Part of Speech? The Grammar Rule That Confuses Even Native Speakers
The sentence "Those is what part of speech?" might seem trivial at first glance, but it exposes a fundamental tension in English grammar—one that trips up learners, native speakers, and even seasoned writers. The confusion stems from a clash between subject-verb agreement and the plurality of pronouns. "Those" is unmistakably plural, yet the verb "is" (singular) often sneaks in where "are" (plural) should reign. This mismatch isn’t just a typo; it’s a linguistic quirk rooted in how English evolved from Old English, where gendered pronouns dominated before shifting toward modern plural forms.
What makes the issue worse is that "those" isn’t just a pronoun—it’s a demonstrative determiner that can function as an adjective or a pronoun, depending on context. When used as a pronoun (e.g., "Those are the ones I meant"), it demands a plural verb. But when misapplied as a singular subject (e.g., "Those is the problem"), it violates grammatical harmony. The error persists because English speakers often default to "is" for proximity to singular subjects, even when the antecedent is clearly plural.
The stakes matter more than you’d think. In formal writing, academic papers, or professional communication, such slips can undermine credibility. Yet, the mistake is so pervasive that it’s rarely corrected—unless you’re a grammar purist or an editor with a red pen. Understanding why this happens requires peeling back layers of linguistic history, syntactic rules, and even cognitive shortcuts the brain takes when processing language.

The Complete Overview of "Those Is What Part of Speech"
At its core, "those is what part of speech?" is a question about subject-verb agreement, one of the most foundational yet frequently overlooked rules in English grammar. The phrase "those is" is grammatically incorrect because "those" is a plural demonstrative pronoun, and plural subjects require plural verbs (e.g., "are," "were," "have"). The confusion arises because "those" can also act as a determiner (e.g., "those books are mine"), where it modifies a plural noun but still triggers a plural verb. The key distinction lies in whether "those" stands alone as a subject or precedes a noun—both cases demand "are," not "is."The error becomes more pronounced in spoken language, where contractions (e.g., "that’s" for "that is") blur the line between singular and plural usage. Many speakers unconsciously default to "is" when the subject feels singular in meaning, even if the word itself is plural. For example, "Those is a lot of work" might sound natural to some because "work" is uncountable, but grammatically, "those" remains plural. This disconnect highlights how English’s syntactic rules sometimes conflict with intuitive speech patterns.
Historical Background and Evolution
The roots of this grammatical tension lie in Old English, where pronouns were heavily gendered and number distinctions were more rigid. "That" (neuter singular) and "þæt" (demonstrative) evolved into Modern English’s "that" and "those," with "those" emerging as the plural form. However, the shift toward a more analytical language—where function often overrides form—led to ambiguities. By the Middle English period, "those" had solidified as plural, yet speakers retained habits from earlier stages where demonstratives could blur singular/plural lines.The Great Vowel Shift of the 15th–18th centuries further complicated matters by altering pronunciation, making it harder to distinguish between "that" (singular) and "those" (plural) in speech. Written English, governed by prescriptive grammar rules, eventually codified "those" as strictly plural, but the oral tradition lagged. Today, the persistence of "those is" reflects this historical lag—a remnant of how language evolves faster in speech than in formal rules.
Core Mechanisms: How It Works
Grammatically, "those" functions as a demonstrative pronoun when it replaces a noun (e.g., "I like those" instead of "I like those apples"). In this role, it’s always plural, requiring "are," "were," or another plural verb. The brain’s tendency to match verbs based on semantic proximity (e.g., the noun following "those") rather than grammatical number is what causes errors. For instance:Table of Contents
- The Complete Overview of "Those Is What Part of Speech"
- Historical Background and Evolution
- Core Mechanisms: How It Works
- Key Benefits and Crucial Impact
- Major Advantages
- Comparative Analysis
- Future Trends and Innovations
- Conclusion
- Comprehensive FAQs
- Q: Why do people say "those is" instead of "those are" ?
- Q: Is "those is" ever correct in any context?
- Q: How can I remember the correct form?
- Q: Does this rule apply to other demonstratives, like *"this" or "that"?
- Q: Are there exceptions where "those is" might be acceptable?
- Q: How does this compare to similar errors in other languages?
The mechanism breaks down when "those" is misused as a singular subject, a mistake that’s more common in informal speech. Cognitive studies suggest that speakers often prioritize referential clarity (focusing on the noun being described) over strict grammatical rules, leading to "those is" in contexts like "Those is the reason why."
Key Benefits and Crucial Impact
Mastering the distinction between "those is" and "those are" isn’t just about avoiding errors—it’s about precision in communication. In fields like law, academia, and technical writing, where clarity is non-negotiable, such slips can distort meaning or introduce ambiguity. For example, a legal document stating "Those is the terms of agreement" might unintentionally suggest that the terms are singular, leading to contractual misunderstandings.The rule also serves as a microcosm of broader linguistic principles, such as agreement in number and subject-verb concord, which apply across languages. Recognizing these patterns sharpens one’s ability to parse complex sentences, a skill invaluable in editing, translation, and even artificial intelligence-driven language processing. The impact extends to education, where teachers use such examples to illustrate how grammar reflects logic and structure.
"Grammar is the logic of language, and logic is the grammar of the mind." — Noam Chomsky
Major Advantages
- Clarity in Writing: Correct usage eliminates ambiguity, ensuring readers grasp the intended meaning without hesitation.
- Professional Credibility: Errors like "those is" can make writing appear careless, whereas precision signals attention to detail.
- Cognitive Consistency: Adhering to grammatical rules reinforces logical thinking, a skill transferable to problem-solving in other areas.
- Cross-Linguistic Awareness: Understanding English’s quirks helps learners navigate similar structures in other languages (e.g., Spanish’s "esos son" vs. "eso es").
- Technical Accuracy: In programming, data analysis, or scientific writing, grammatical precision mirrors the need for syntactic correctness in code or formulas.

Comparative Analysis
| Feature | Those (Plural) | That (Singular) |
|---|---|---|
| Function | Demonstrative pronoun/determiner (plural reference) | Demonstrative pronoun/determiner (singular/neuter reference) |
| Verb Agreement | Requires plural verb ("are," "were") | Requires singular verb ("is," "was") |
| Common Mistake | Those is (incorrect) |
That are (incorrect) |
| Example Correction | Those are the files you need. | That is the file you need. |
Future Trends and Innovations
As language continues to evolve, the rigidity of subject-verb agreement may soften in informal contexts, particularly with the rise of digital communication (texting, social media) where grammar rules are often relaxed. However, formal writing and AI-driven language models will likely enforce stricter adherence to traditional rules, as precision remains critical in automated systems. Innovations in grammar-checking tools may also flag "those is" errors more aggressively, nudging users toward correctness.The future may see a hybrid approach: while spoken English embraces flexibility, written and technical communication will prioritize clarity and consistency. For now, the debate over "those is" serves as a reminder that language is both a living organism and a structured system—one that rewards those who understand its rules, even when they’re bent.

Conclusion
The question "those is what part of speech?" is more than a grammatical curiosity—it’s a window into how language balances structure and fluidity. While "those" is undeniably plural, the persistence of "those is" reveals deeper trends in linguistic evolution, cognitive processing, and the tension between spoken and written norms. For writers, speakers, and learners, recognizing this pattern isn’t just about correcting mistakes; it’s about honing the ability to communicate with precision, whether in an essay, a boardroom, or a casual conversation.Ultimately, grammar isn’t about restriction—it’s about intentionality. Every rule, including the one governing "those is," exists to serve clarity. By mastering it, you’re not just avoiding errors; you’re wielding language with the same care as a sculptor shaping clay.
Comprehensive FAQs
Q: Why do people say "those is" instead of "those are"?
The error stems from semantic proximity—speakers focus on the noun following "those" (e.g., "the problem") and default to a singular verb ("is") based on the noun’s perceived singularity, even though "those" itself is plural. This is a cognitive shortcut, not a rule.
Q: Is "those is" ever correct in any context?
No. "Those" is always plural, so "is" is grammatically incorrect in all standard English usage. Even in dialectal variations (e.g., some African American Vernacular English), "those is" is nonstandard and would be marked as incorrect in formal contexts.
Q: How can I remember the correct form?
Use the "plural trigger" mnemonic: If you can replace "those" with "they" (another plural pronoun), the verb must be plural. Example: "They are the ones I chose" → "Those are the ones I chose." This forces the brain to prioritize grammatical number over semantic context.
Q: Does this rule apply to other demonstratives, like *"this" or "that"?
Yes. "This" and "that" are singular when used as pronouns (e.g., "This is heavy"), while "these" and "those" are plural (e.g., "These are mine"). The key is whether the demonstrative refers to one thing ("that") or multiple ("those").
Q: Are there exceptions where "those is" might be acceptable?
In poetic license or deliberate stylistic choices, authors may bend rules for effect (e.g., "Those is the night the stars forgot to shine" in a song lyric). However, this is rare and context-dependent. For most purposes, strict adherence to "those are" is expected.
Q: How does this compare to similar errors in other languages?
Many languages have analogous issues. For example, in Spanish, "eso es" (that is) becomes "esos son" (those are), but errors like "esos es" occur in informal speech. French has similar plural-singular verb mismatches (e.g., "ce sont" vs. "c’est"), showing that subject-verb agreement is a universal grammatical challenge.
Leave a Comment
Comments are moderated before appearing. The data you submit is processed according to the Privacy Policy of kiwiirc.com.