The Art of Not the Best but Still Good—Why Mediocrity Has Its Place

Published

The human obsession with perfection is a modern paradox. We chase flawless products, relentless productivity, and unattainable standards—yet the pursuit often leaves us exhausted, disappointed, and financially drained. In contrast, there’s a quiet, underrated virtue in settling for not the best but still good. It’s the unglamorous middle ground between excellence and failure, a pragmatic stance that prioritizes sustainability over superlatives. This isn’t about laziness; it’s a calculated rejection of unnecessary friction in a world that glorifies extremes.

Consider the last time you agonized over a minor purchase: the $200 shoes that "might" be worth it, the premium coffee that costs more than your weekly groceries, or the software subscription you barely use. The cognitive load of these decisions is exhausting. Yet, the alternative—embracing adequate options—can free mental bandwidth for what truly matters. The problem? Society frames "good enough" as a cop-out, when in reality, it’s often the wiser choice.

The concept isn’t new. Philosophers, economists, and even military strategists have long advocated for the good-enough principle—whether it’s Sun Tzu’s "victory without battle" or the Japanese mottainai (wastefulness in excess). In an era of hyper-choice and performative excellence, the ability to recognize not the best but still good is a skill worth mastering.

not the best but still good

The Complete Overview of "Not the Best but Still Good"

At its core, "not the best but still good" is a mental framework that reframes value away from absolute superiority and toward functional adequacy. It’s the difference between a $5,000 watch that tells time perfectly and a $50 watch that does the job without draining your savings. It’s choosing a second-hand book over a first edition, a generic brand over a luxury label, or a 7/10 experience over an 8/10 one that requires excessive effort. The beauty lies in its flexibility—it’s not about lowering standards but optimizing for enough.

This principle thrives in domains where marginal gains don’t justify the cost. A chef might use a slightly cheaper ingredient if the flavor difference is negligible; a parent might buy a well-rated but not top-tier stroller if it means saving for college. The key is recognizing when the diminishing returns of perfectionism outweigh the benefits. Psychologists call this satisficing—a term coined by Herbert Simon to describe decisions that are "sufficiently good" rather than optimal. It’s a rebellion against the tyranny of "more is better," especially when "more" demands disproportionate time, money, or energy.

Historical Background and Evolution

The idea of accepting good enough has roots in ancient Stoicism, where philosophers like Epictetus argued that happiness comes from controlling perceptions, not external outcomes. A Stoic might wear a patched cloak or eat simple food without guilt, because the mind’s peace outweighed material deficiencies. This wasn’t resignation; it was strategic detachment from unnecessary strife. Fast-forward to the 20th century, and economists like John Maynard Keynes observed that beyond a certain point, additional wealth doesn’t increase happiness—a concept now known as the hedonic treadmill. Keynes himself lived frugally, rejecting the cult of consumerism decades before it became mainstream.

The modern iteration of this philosophy gained traction in the 1990s with the rise of minimalism and anti-consumerism movements. Figures like Joshua Fields Millburn and Ryan Nicodemus popularized the idea that owning less (but better) leads to greater freedom. Meanwhile, behavioral economists like Dan Ariely demonstrated how people often overpay for incremental improvements—like upgrading from a $100 laptop to a $1,500 one for a 10% speed boost. The term "good enough" entered mainstream discourse as a counter to the paradox of choice, where more options paradoxically lead to dissatisfaction.

Core Mechanisms: How It Works

The psychology behind "not the best but still good" revolves around two cognitive biases: loss aversion and the endowment effect. Loss aversion (Kahneman & Tversky) explains why we fear missing out on a "better" option more than we enjoy settling for adequate—even if the difference is trivial. The endowment effect makes us overvalue what we already own, leading to irrational upgrades. Overcoming these requires a deliberate shift in perspective: instead of asking "Is this the absolute best?", ask "Does this solve my problem well enough?"

Table of Contents

Practically, this mindset relies on three levers:
1. Threshold Setting: Define what "good enough" means for each context (e.g., "This coffee is 80% as good as my favorite, but I’ll drink it anyway").
2. Opportunity Cost Awareness: Calculate the hidden costs of chasing perfection (time, money, stress) versus the benefits gained.
3. Deliberate Underdogging: Actively seek not the best options—like choosing a budget airline over a luxury one—to reclaim mental space.

Tools like the 10/10/10 rule (Suzy Welch) or the 5-second rule (Mel Robbins) can help. The former asks: "Will this matter in 10 months, 10 years, or 10 minutes?"—a litmus test for trivial upgrades. The latter encourages immediate action to bypass overthinking. Both are tactical ways to bypass the paralysis of analysis that perfectionism breeds.

Key Benefits and Crucial Impact

The most immediate benefit of embracing "not the best but still good" is stress reduction. Studies show that people who prioritize adequacy over excellence report lower anxiety levels, partly because they avoid the decision fatigue of endless comparisons. Financial psychologist Brad Klontz found that consumers who buy good-enough products allocate savings to experiences (travel, hobbies) that correlate with higher long-term happiness—whereas material upgrades rarely do.

Another advantage is time efficiency. The average American spends 17 hours per week researching purchases, according to a Nielsen study. That’s nearly a full workweek wasted on optimization. Shifting to good-enough decisions reclaims hours for relationships, creativity, or rest. Even Elon Musk, a self-proclaimed perfectionist, admits to using "first principles" thinking to cut through unnecessary complexity—essentially, asking "What’s the simplest version that works?"

"Perfection is the enemy of progress. The real world doesn’t reward the best—it rewards the done." — James Clear

Major Advantages

  • Financial Freedom: Avoiding premium pricing on non-essential items (e.g., streaming services, gadgets) can save thousands annually. A 2022 Bankrate study found that Americans waste $3,000/year on unused subscriptions—money that could fund a good-enough vacation or emergency fund.
  • Environmental Sustainability: Fast fashion, disposable tech, and single-use products thrive on the illusion that "better" equals "more durable." Opting for good-enough durable goods (e.g., a $100 well-made bag over a $200 trendy one) reduces waste.
  • Reduced Cognitive Load: The brain’s decision-making muscle is limited. Psychologist Roy Baumeister’s ego depletion theory shows that willpower is a finite resource. Simplifying choices preserves mental energy for high-stakes decisions.
  • Happier Relationships: Couples who agree on good-enough standards (e.g., dining out, home decor) avoid conflicts over trivial preferences. Research in Journal of Personality and Social Psychology links shared "enoughness" to higher relationship satisfaction.
  • Innovation Through Constraints: Many breakthroughs (e.g., the iPhone, Tesla’s early models) emerged from good-enough prototypes. Constraints force creativity—something luxury budgets often stifle.

not the best but still good - Ilustrasi 2

Comparative Analysis

Criteria Not the Best but Still Good Chasing the Best
Time Investment Minimal (e.g., 10 minutes to choose a book) High (e.g., 3 hours researching the "perfect" laptop)
Financial Cost Low to moderate (e.g., $30 for a reliable umbrella) High (e.g., $150 for a "premium" umbrella with minor upgrades)
Stress Level Low (decision made quickly, no buyer’s remorse) High (doubt lingers post-purchase, "what if there’s a better option?")
Long-Term Satisfaction Steady (no hype-induced disappointment) Variable (often overhyped, underdelivered)
Note: The "best" is subjective and often overvalued. A $2,000 Swiss watch may be "better" than a $50 Timex, but if you’re not a watch collector, the difference is irrelevant. The good-enough movement is evolving alongside technological and cultural shifts. AI and automation are making "best" options more accessible—but at a cost. Algorithmic personalization (e.g., Netflix recommendations, Amazon’s "Frequently Bought Together") trains users to expect hyper-optimized choices, increasing dissatisfaction when reality falls short. The backlash? A rise in "digital minimalism" (Cal Newport) and "anti-algorithmic" consumerism, where people deliberately avoid tailored suggestions to rediscover serendipity.

Another trend is circular economy products, where good-enough durability is prioritized over planned obsolescence. Brands like Patagonia and Muji thrive by selling long-lasting, unpretentious goods—proving that adequate can be aspirational. Even tech giants are catching on: Apple’s used refurbished program and Google’s Project Starline (virtual meetings over premium hardware) reflect a shift toward functional excellence over flashy upgrades.

not the best but still good - Ilustrasi 3

Conclusion

"Not the best but still good" isn’t a call for mediocrity—it’s a manifesto for intentionality. In a world that equates worth with extremes, the middle path offers a rare kind of liberation. It’s the difference between a life cluttered with half-used premium items and one rich in experiences, relationships, and unburdened choices. The challenge isn’t in identifying good enough; it’s in overcoming the cultural conditioning that labels it as failure.

The irony? The most "excellent" lives often belong to those who master the art of settling—not out of laziness, but out of wisdom. As the Stoics knew, true freedom lies not in having the best, but in needing the least.

Comprehensive FAQs

Q: How do I know when to choose "not the best but still good"?

A: Ask these three questions:
1. Is the difference between this and the "best" option meaningful to me? (e.g., 5% better performance vs. 50% better).
2. What’s the opportunity cost? (e.g., time spent researching vs. time with family).
3. Will I regret the "best" option in 6 months, or just the price I paid for it? If the answer to any of these leans toward good enough, prioritize adequacy.

Q: Isn’t this just an excuse to be lazy?

A: No—it’s a strategic rejection of busywork. Laziness avoids effort; good-enough thinking avoids fruitless effort. The key difference is intent. A lazy person might skip brushing their teeth; someone practicing good enough might use a $5 toothbrush instead of a $20 one without compromising oral health.

Q: What if "good enough" leads to lower quality in important areas (e.g., healthcare, education)?

A: The principle applies to non-critical areas. Healthcare and education are exceptions where best is non-negotiable. The framework works best for discretionary spending (entertainment, gadgets, decor) where marginal gains don’t justify the cost. Think of it as a triage system: allocate "best" resources where it matters most, and good enough elsewhere.

Q: How can I convince my partner/family to adopt this mindset?

A: Frame it as a shared experiment:

  • Start with low-stakes items (e.g., "Let’s try the store-brand cereal for a month").
  • Track savings or time reclaimed (e.g., "We saved $200 this month—what could we do with that?").
  • Use humor: "If we spent this much on avocado toast, we’d never afford therapy."
  • Most resistance comes from habit, not logic—small wins build momentum.

    Q: Are there industries where "not the best but still good" is harmful?

    A: Yes. In fields like aviation, medicine, or engineering, good enough can be catastrophic. The principle is context-dependent. Use it for:
    ✅ Personal lifestyle choices
    ✅ Non-critical purchases
    ✅ Low-risk decisions
    ❌ Safety-critical systems
    ❌ Long-term investments (e.g., retirement planning)
    The rule of thumb: If failure has severe consequences, aim for the best. If not, aim for enough.

    Q: What’s the biggest misconception about this philosophy?

    A: That it’s about lowering standards. In reality, it’s about raising them—just not for the wrong things. A chef who uses a $20 knife instead of a $200 one isn’t settling; they’re redirecting resources to better ingredients, training, or rest. The misconception stems from equating good enough with inferior—when it’s often the opposite.